Anne Hathaway has portrayed a princess, Catwoman, and an overworked fashion assistant in a story loosely inspired by Anna Wintour. But TLC has now given her perhaps the most unusual role of her career: a potential lookalike of Colorado’s infamous Mad Pooper.
In an exclusive clip from the network’s upcoming documentary, a witness is shown photographs of women who bear a resemblance to the unidentified jogger. He briefly picks out the Oscar-winning actress before discovering whose face he had actually been looking at.
The producers initially present the witness with a woman identified as Kayla, a former Colorado Springs Police Department dispatcher who was reportedly identified by someone as a possible suspect. Kayla also had an arrest on her record for allegedly trying to steal a hot dog cart while intoxicated, which somehow turns out to be only the second-most outrageous detail in the scene.
The witness quickly rules her out with a firm “definite no” before moving on to another photograph, which catches his attention for considerably longer.
“The hair is right, the face is right,” the white-haired witness says as he examines the next woman. “Possibility here.” However, that possibility is immediately ruled out when someone off-camera informs him, “The one in the middle is Academy Award winner Anne Hathaway.”
The witness bursts into laughter after realizing he has just linked the star of The Princess Diaries to a years-long investigation into a woman accused of repeatedly defecating on lawns across Colorado.
Hathaway’s photo was apparently included as a control to see whether the witness could recognize the Mad Pooper’s general facial features and build. “She’s not a suspect,” a producer clarifies, explaining that the team simply wanted to test whether her “body and face type” matched that of the mystery jogger.
Although Hathaway was quickly ruled out, the remaining photographs offered no major breakthrough. When asked whether any of the women could be responsible, the witness admitted he couldn’t confidently identify the culprit.
Just like that, the investigation was back to square one.
The bizarre case dates back to 2017, when Colorado Springs resident Cathy Budde reported that an unidentified jogger was repeatedly using the area outside her family’s home as a toilet. Budde’s children first spotted the woman squatting outside before alerting their mother, who eventually confronted her.
According to Budde, the jogger responded, “Yeah, sorry,” but continued showing up approximately once a week.
Despite having access to nearby public restrooms, the woman apparently chose to ignore them. Reports that she carried napkins also suggested she was considerably more prepared than the average runner caught in an emergency.
Colorado Springs police investigated the incidents as possible public defecation and indecent exposure, but the woman was never publicly identified. The bizarre case eventually attracted national attention, with Charmin even offering the culprit a year’s supply of toilet paper if she turned herself in.
TLC’s two-hour documentary, The Mad Pooper, premieres Nov. 19 at 8 p.m. ET/PT.
